At Lighthouse Insurance Agency, we exceed expectations.
A culture of doing the right things.
Anyone can promise great service, but not everyone can deliver it. At Lighthouse Insurance Agency, we’ve built a culture around doing the right things. But don’t just take our word for it. Read these client testimonials to see exactly what we mean.
“Love them! They are always so helpful and friendly. Getting new insurance on my car and motorcycle was super quick and easy.”Randi Lewis
“I was hit by an uninsured driver and Brian and Matt made my claim go through so fast and everything was perfect. I had a rental on the same day. I never had to worry about anything. Lighthouse has taken great care of my family and I always refer my friends and family.”Jake Sosinski
“Love Lighthouse! Great service and people!”Denise Abraham-blatt
“My sister's friend was telling me how much money the company saved her, her father who owned a lot of property, and my sister‘s neighbor also bought her insurance from this company, so I thought why not call him? So I did. They saved us $540 a year! That was without bundling home and auto! We also decided to get car insurance through them because it actually was a much better policy than what we had, including accident forgiveness. They did all the work, I did nothing but sign my name on the dotted line, and it only took minutes!”Deborah PufnockAnother satisfied customer
“Lighthouse provides us all of our insurance needs: auto, home, life and umbrella. The service, location and billing options are very helpful and convenient. I have been a client of Lighthouse for the past 16 years and planning on another 16 in the future. Thanks for all your help.”Darlene Morrison
“This place and these people are wonderful! They have helped me save so much money and still getting great coverage! Definitely recommend lighthouse!”Brittany Warren
“Donna Sebo and Matt Metzger were great to work with. They went over my policy and made some suggestions to save money without changing my coverage. I like knowing I can call and get a response quickly or I can stop in. Great customer service!!!!”Deborah Brown Dalehite
“I would highly recommend Brian and his team for all of your insurance needs. They are very helpful and go the extra mile to make sure that their insured is taken care of.”Michelle Santiago
“Love them! They are always so helpful and friendly. Getting new insurance on my car & motorcycle was super quick and easy.”Randi Lewis
“Always great customer service!”Sara Sebo
“Great staff and very helpful!!!”Julie David Hildebrandt
“I was at my sisters house a couple of weeks ago and her manicurist was there and somehow we got on the subject of the outrageous cost of insurance. Something ALL of us deal with. I find it really annoying that you pay a boatload of money to protect you if an accident happens but when it does you get penalized by either having the company say bye-bye or higher rates. Anyway, this girl went on and on about this insurance company in Amherst which is where I was at the time. She was telling me how much money the company saved her, AND her father who owned a lot of property and supposedly the company saved him tons of money, AND my sister‘s neighbor also bought her insurance from this company, so I thought why not call him? So I did.. Took over a copy of our policies…BOTTOM LINE, They saved us $540 a year! That was without bundling auto & car! But today we also decided to get car insurance through them because it actually was a much better policy than what we had, including ACCIDENT FORGIVENESS... they did all the work I did nothing but sign my name on the dotted line, and it only took minutes! So totally worth it! Give him a call, unless you don’t need to save money.”Deborah Pufnock
Request an Insurance Quote
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
Get a Quote
It only takes a minute to get started.
- Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
- Go over your options with an agent.
- Get the coverage you need.